Elimination Reactions

By James Ashenhurst

Elimination (E1) Reactions With Rearrangements

Last updated: November 2nd, 2020 |

Elimination Reactions (E1) That Occur With Rearrangements – Hydride Or Alkyl Shifts

Where there are carbocations (see last post), rearrangement reactions are never far behind. Our old friends have come back for a short visit in this chapter on elimination reactions.

Table of Contents

  1. What’s Weird About This Elimination Reaction?
  2. Elimination (E1) With Hydride Shift
  3. Elimination (E1) With Alkyl Shift
  4. (Advanced) References and Further Reading

1. What’s Weird About This Elimination Reaction?

One last (weird) reaction to show you with respect to elimination reactions. Can you see what’s weird about it?

e1 reaction elimination with hydride shift giving zaitsev alkene

How did that double bond get over there? Normally when elimination occurs, we remove a hydrogen from the carbon adjacent to the leaving group. But here, something extra has taken place.

2. Elimination (E1) With Rearrangement: Hydride Shift

Let’s look at all the bonds that form and the bonds that break so we can track down exactly what happens:

elimination e1 with rearrangement full list of bonds formed and broken migration of double bond

Notice how it differs from a typical elimination reaction? Sure, we’re forming C-C (π), and breaking C-H and C-OH, but we have an extra C-H that forms and an extra C-H that breaks.

This is a sure sign of a rearrangement step!

So what’s going on here?

Well, we start by protonating the alcohol. This allows for water to leave in the next step, which is going to form a carbocation. Here’s the thing: the carbocation is secondary, and we’re adjacent to a tertiary carbon. So if the hydrogen (and its pair of electrons) were to migrate from C3 in our example to C-2, we’d now have a tertiary carbocation, which is more stable. Then, a base (water in this example) could remove C-H, forming the more substituted alkene (the Zaitsev product in this case). And that’s how the alkene ends up there.

mechanism for e1 with rearrangement acid loss giving carbocation rearrangement then deprotonation

OK. So that’s one mystery solved.

3. Elimination (E1) With Rearrangement: Alkyl Shift

You might remember that these types of rearrangements can occur in SN1 reactions too. And if you read that post, you might recall that in addition to shifts of hydrogen (“hydride”, because there’s a pair of electrons attached) we can also have alkyl shifts. Here’s a final example. Note – I’ve also made a video of this, you can watch it here.

elimination e1 with alkyl shift migrating methyl group followed by deprotonation

This pretty much does it for elimination reactions.

In the next series of posts, let’s go though one of the biggest questions students struggle with. Okay, now that we’ve gone through substitution and elimination reactions, HOW DO WE DECIDE WHICH ONE IS GOING TO OCCUR IN EACH SITUATION?

Great question. That’s next.

Next Series, post 1: SN1/SN2/E1/E2 Decision (1) – The Substrate


(Advanced) References and Further Reading

  1. Check this paper out for some very clean, classic examples of dehydration with alkyl shift. The authors take 1-cyclohexyl-1-methylethanol and treat it with either TsOH/benzene or BF3•OEt2. You might think that they’d get the tetrasubstituted olefin, but the dominant product is the trisubstituted alkene (90:10). Reason is greater acidity of the axial C-H bonds which are aligned with the intermediate carbocation.
    BF3·OEt2 Promotes Fast, Mild, Clean and Regioselective Dehydration of Tertiary Alcohols.

    Posner, G. H.; Shulman-Roskes, E. M.; Oh, C. H.; Carry, J.-C.; Green, J. V.; Clark, A. B.; Dai, H.; Anjeh, T. E. N.
    Tetrahedron Lett. 1991, 32 (45), 6489–6492.
    DOI: 10.1016/0040-4039(91)80200-P

Alcohol dehydration E1 with hydride shift followed by elimination Posner

  1. Neighboring hydrogen, isotope effect, and conformation in solvolysis of 3-methyl-2-butyl p-toluenesulfonate
    S. Winstein, J. Takahashi
    Tetrahedron 1958, 2 (3-4), 316-321
    DOI:
    10.1016/0040-4020(58)88053-9
    3-methyl-2-butyl-tosylate is an example of a system that rearranges readily under solvolysis, which is illustrated in Table 3.
  2. Mechanisms of elimination reactions. XIII. Effect of base, solvent, and structure on product ratios in elimination reactions of some secondary tosylates
    Irving N. Feit and William H. Saunders
    Journal of the American Chemical Society 1970, 92 (6), 1630-1634
    DOI:
    1021/ja00709a035
    Towards the end, this paper states, “An interesting sidelight of the E1 reactions is that the olefins resulting from hydride shift with 2-methyl-3-pentyl and 3-methyl-2-butyl tosylates, 2-methyl- 1 -pentene, and 2-methyl-l-butene, respectively, are found in increasing amounts along the solvent series n-BuOH <s-BuOH < t-BuOH.”
  3. REARRANGEMENT STUDIES WITH C14: IX. THE FORMOLYSIS OF METHYL-C14-ISOPROPYLCARBINYL p-TOLUENESULPHONATE
    J. Finlayson and C. C. Lee
    Can. J. Chem. 1960, 38, 787-792
    DOI: 10.1139/v60-114
    Another study of the same system from Ref. 1, this uses C14 labeling to study the course of the rearrangements – see pg. 700.
  4. Über die Pinakolinumlagerung cyclischer Verbindungen
    Hans Meerwein, Walter Unkel
    Lieb. Ann. Chem. 1910, 376 (2), 152-163
    DOI:
    10.1002/jlac.19103760203
    This paper by Hans Meerwein, an early pioneer in the study of carbocations and acid-catalyzed rearrangements, is on pinacol and semipinacolic rearrangements. In this paper, he demonstrates that 2,2-dimethylcyclohexanol is converted by acid into a mixture of isopropylidenecyclopentane and 1,2-dimethylcyclohexene.
  5. Über Ringveränderungen bei der Wasserabspaltung aus alicyclischen Alkoholen
    Hans Meerwein
    Lieb. Ann. Chem. 1918, 417 (2-3), 255-257
    DOI:
    10.1002/jlac.19184170205
  6. The Common Basis of Intramolecular Rearrangements. II.1 The Dehydration of Di-tert-butylcarbinol and the Conversion of the Resulting Nonenes to Trimethylethylene and Isobutylene
    Frank C. Whitmore and E. E. Stahly
    Journal of the American Chemical Society 1933, 55 (10), 4153-4157
    DOI:
    1021/ja01337a042
    Prof. F. C. Whitmore is mentioned in reviews on the history of carbocation chemistry, as he was the first person to suggest that carbocations be represented with an ‘open sextet’ of electrons and draw them as such.
  7. Mechanism of substitution at a saturated carbon atom. Part XXIX. The rôle of steric hindrance. (Section D) the mechanism of the reaction of neopentyl bromide with aqueous ethyl alcohol
    I. Dostrovsky and E. D. Hughes
    J. Chem. Soc., 1946, 166-169
    DOI:
    10.1039/JR9460000166
    Under the conditions used here (aqueous ethanol with NaOH), about 36% of rearranged olefin (trimethylethylene) was obtained from neopentyl bromide. Likely higher yields of olefin would be possible if acidic conditions are employed, which favor formation of carbocations.
  8. Lanostane to Cucurbitane Transformations.
    Edwards, O. E.; Kolt, R. J. .
    Can. J. Chem. 1987, 65 (3), 595–612.
    DOI: 10.1139/v87-104
    The authors take a very rigid system (the steroid lanostane) containing a tertiary alcohol and observe what happens when it is dehydrated with strong acid (H2SO4 – AcOH – Ac2O, so-called, “Westphalen conditions”). After loss of water, a methyl shift from the adjacent quaternary carbon is observed (NOT a hydride shift, interestingly!) and the authors compare the ratio of alkenes (trisubstituted vs tetrasubstituted). Ratios are greatly affected by subtle electronic effects of remote groups.
  9. A Mild One-Pot Method for Conversion of Various Steroidal Secondary Alcohols into the Corresponding Olefins.
    Kumar, R. R.; Haveli, S. D.; Kagan, H. B.
    Synlett 2011, 2011 (12), 1709–1712.
    DOI: 10.1055/s-0030-1260803
    Slightly different steroid system, giving mixture of rearrangement + elimination products.steroid system elimination of triflate with 1 2 alkyl shift kagan

Comments

Comment section

2 thoughts on “Elimination (E1) Reactions With Rearrangements

  1. Hi , thanks for your great post, i am 16 but i love chemistry and i am going to paticipate in IChO.but a question, if both alkyl and hydrid shift is possible, what will happen?

    1. Hydride shifts, generally, will perform 1,2 shifts much faster than alkyl shifts. First, think about the driving force for a 1,2 shift. The driving force is formation of a less substituted carbocation. If you have a secondary carbocation adjacent to a tertiary carbon, and the tertiary C-H migrates, you obtain a (more stable) tertiary carbocation. However if an alkyl group migrates, you obtain an (equally stable) secondary carbocation.

      Exceptions can occur. In the lab, there are cases where 1,2- alkyl shifts will happen preferentially, especially in rigid cyclic systems. In rigid, cyclic systems containing a free carbocation the groups likeliest to migrate are those which have their bonds aligned with the empty p-orbital; axial groups, in other words. See the references at the end of the post for some examples.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.